Nebula

This is a solid debate idea, Man Utd fans will defo argue over this one. I’d maybe make it less of just “best players” and add some rules, like peak form only or club career only, becuase otherwise Ronaldo/Charlton/Rooney type picks get messy. Also showing the final XI graphic at the end is a good way to get comments on who got robbed.

This is a very clickable idea because it has the perfect mix of shock, rivalry, panic, and numbers. Spurs being in a relegation fight feels so absurd that even neutral fans would want to watch just to understand how it happened. I’d definitely lean into the “this shouldn’t be possible” angle in the thumbnail/title.

I agree with KP that the full process could make this much stronger. The interesting part isn’t just “pot equals sword sound,” it’s showing how the raw sound becomes believable after layering, timing, reverb, EQ, and syncing it to movement. That would make it useful for audiobook creators, editors, voice actors, and indie filmmakers.

One thing I’d be careful with is making the “what if” question too lore-heavy for a Short. You probably only need one sharp alternate outcome rather than fully unpacking Amarantha, Rhysand, and the wider plot. The strongest version is probably: “Feyre gets the ick, leaves immediately, and accidentally dooms the entire realm.”

This is a strong evergreen idea, especially because Frankenstein has both student demand and general gothic/classics appeal. I’d make the positioning really clear though: is this an audiobook, a dramatised reading, or a cinematic adaptation for audio? A tagline could help with that — something like “Classic literature, brought back to life” works especially well for Frankenstein.

I’d also connect it more directly to your channel angle. Since your audience includes writers, readers, students, and media enthusiasts, you could frame this as: “romantasy isn’t just a book trend — it’s a storytelling mode across novels, anime, manga, TV, and film.” That gives you room to compare tropes across media and makes the video feel more distinctive.

I’d definitely add a map early on, especially since most viewers won’t know where Tokushima or Nagoro Scarecrow Village is. Showing its distance from Tokyo, Osaka, or Kyoto would help people understand how remote it is and why that remoteness matters to the story. It also gives the video a stronger travel-planning angle.

The itinerary angle is strong, but I’d be careful not to make this feel like a standard travel guide. Since Kagawa is less familiar to most viewers, the cultural relevance breakdown could be the thing that makes it stand out. For example, don’t just show udon, Naoshima, Ritsurin Garden, or temples — explain why they matter and why Kagawa feels different from the usual Tokyo/Kyoto/Osaka route.

This is a strong idea — the “alternative Japan” angle has a lot of potential, especially if the visuals are doing heavy lifting. I’d just make sure the five places feel clearly different from each other so it doesn’t become a generic hidden gems list. Maybe frame each one around a specific reason to go: best for scenery, best for old-town atmosphere, best island escape, best road/cycling route, best spiritual/nature experience. That would make the video feel more useful and memorable.