RomantasyFanatic

Member since Apr 2026

5 ideas • 16 total upvotes

Video Title

What if: Feyre gets the Ick from Tamlin

Category

Shorts

Hook

Reading the passage of ACOTAR where Tamlin plays the fiddle and she swoons - throws the book into the bin.

High Level Video Summary

Super extra, cringe role play of alternate timelines/ endings. This would be a series for popular books/ movies/ shows/ anime.

Detailed Video Script

Focus on ACOTAR what if Feyre got the ick and left Tamlin. Would Amarantha have won? Would Rysand have killed her?

Target Audience

Romance fans, 20-40 y/o, cringe humour

Tags

Not provided.

Why will this video succeed?

Memes of popular series are gaining traction but theyre usually done by men. Plus people enjoy theorising about what ifs. Tamlin is also really hated in the fandom so people would love to throw shade there.

Strategic value to your channel

Not provided.

Time to create (hours)

2 hrs

Draft video URL

Not provided.

Expected views

Not provided.

Closest Competitor Similar Video

Not provided.

Benchmark Youtuber Similar Style

Not provided.

Community feedback

6 comments
Log in to add your feedback.
KP

May 5, 2026 04:48

Fun video for those interested in the series. I'm concerned that you may be diversifying your content too much. You mentioned 2 posts on anime and now youre looking at books. I think its better to focus on ome genre first and then switch over so fans know what to expect from you. That being said, the genre is your focus so potentially it could work
3 months ago
KP

May 5, 2026 04:48

Fun video for those interested in the series. I'm concerned that you may be diversifying your content too much. You mentioned 2 posts on anime and now youre looking at books. I think its better to focus on ome genre first and then switch over so fans know what to expect from you. That being said, the genre is your focus so potentially it could work
3 months ago
RomantasyFanatic

May 11, 2026 02:24

I'm planning to emphasise the focus on genre in my first video and then hop around media-wise. So long as I don't focus too much on one medium, the emphasis should remain on genre, preventing people from associating me with a particular medium.
2 months ago
Nebula

May 6, 2026 13:45 (edited)

One thing I’d be careful with is making the “what if” question too lore-heavy for a Short. You probably only need one sharp alternate outcome rather than fully unpacking Amarantha, Rhysand, and the wider plot. The strongest version is probably: “Feyre gets the ick, leaves immediately, and accidentally dooms the entire realm.”
2 months ago
RomantasyFanatic

May 11, 2026 02:23

I was thinking a quick 1 min skit similar to Steven’s Book Reviews. I agree, it shouldn't be too long or lore-specific.
2 months ago
My Little Horse

May 27, 2026 11:20

This is a fun Shorts idea, but I would make sure the joke lands in the first second. The book-in-bin moment is probably the hook. I would open there, then make the "what if" question super clear immediately after. The only concern is channel focus. If the account is also doing anime/media explainers, this can still fit, but I would frame it as part of a recurring "alternate endings / what ifs" series so it does not feel random.
2 months ago